This interdisciplinary work explores current controversy over the collective identity of Romani and reasons for their social predicament. The first position, associated with Romani studies and identity politics, sees all Romani as a part of an ‘ethnic group’, and connects their plight to ‘racial’ discrimination and intolerance. Some anthropologists and social policy-makers call this ‘primordialism’ and deconstruct the notion of a unitary and natural ‘Romani nation’, maintaining most ghetto inhabitants are only classified as ‘Romani’ and their identity derives from their ‘sociál exclusion’. Matching policies are advocated. The author combines contemporary anthropological approaches to the identity construction with theories of discourse to conceptualize the debate, completing the framework with self-reflection of social science. The method of Critical Discourse Analysis is applied in examining corpora of academic and specialized writing, policy papers and media texts for the discourse construction of identity. Arguing that both discourses are differentiated instantiations of the same diagram of power normalizing ‘troublesome’ subjectivities, the author touches upon the ethical responsibility of scientists deconstructing essentialist representations of identities and circulating their ovm constructs instead.
Ve svém příspěvku autorka vychází z dlouholeté praxe psychologa působícího
v republikových bezpečnostních sborech. Věnuje se tématům individuální a skupinové identity v prostředí totalitní a posttotalitní společnosti a bezpečnostních institucí. and In her contribution the author builds upon her longstanding experience as a psychologist in Czech security forces. She discusses the themes of individual and group identity in an environment of totalitarian and post-totalitarian society and security institutions.
Ve svém příspěvku autorka vychází z dlouholeté praxe psychologa působícího
v republikových bezpečnostních sborech. Věnuje se tématům individuální a skupinové identity v prostředí totalitní a posttotalitní společnosti a bezpečnostních institucí. and In her contribution the author builds upon her longstanding experience as a psychologist in Czech security forces. She discusses the themes of individual and group identity in an environment of totalitarian and post-totalitarian society and security institutions.